Friday, August 23, 2024

Where do you draw the line?

Jody and I attended a Scripture Reasoning night at the Istanbul Center Tuesday evening. These nights are spent comparing passages from the Torah, Quran, and the New Testament amongst believers from the Jewish, Muslim, and Christian background. Most nights end up about half Muslims and half Christians in attendance. We look forward to these nights as the focus is finding common ground and learning from each other as well as deepening your own faith; not argument or seeking to convince one another. 

This most recent night was focused on modesty. I felt this would be an interesting discussion amongst Muslims and Christians so I invited a female friend to join us.

When we arrived, we were greeted warmly by our Muslim friends, who we have spent time with over the past few years. The women are always so friendly to me. We are encouraged to sit in mixed groups to help foster the discussion. 

Each of the three tables get assigned a passage from one of the Holy books and then have to report on what they gleaned from it. The idea is for each of the passages to address the topic of focus for the night. The passage from the Torah was Genesis 24:64-67. The passage from the New Testament was 1 Timothy 2:8-10, and the passage from the Quran was Light, 24:30-31. 

You can imagine where the conversation gravitated to despite the majority seeking to focus on the parts of Scripture which spoke to issues other than clothing options. As the discussion bounced from table to table, it was remarkable the amount of time men spent talking about women's attire. When the night wrapped up and I went to say my good-byes to my Muslim friends, the women commented on how crazy it was that the men got to speak so much for us. 

As the main moderator was bringing our night to a close, I asked to share a verse. I shared 1 Samuel 16:7- "But the Lord said to Samuel, "Do not look on his appearance or on the height of his stature, because I have rejected him. For the Lord sees not as man sees: man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart."

This verse has brought me immense peace and comfort and I felt it was necessary to end our discussion that seemed to keep coming back to judging a person's righteousness based on their attire, on the fact that our Lord has a different standard. I pointed out that a person could be dressed in a way that seemed righteous yet with a filthy heart and vice versa. 

I was at the table with the Imam of the largest Mosque in our city. He brought up Mary, the mother of Jesus, and spoke of how highly regarded she is in their faith. He pointed out how she is clothed in the portraits of her and how pious a woman she was. 

I have pondered in recent years why we do not give Mary more attention in my faith; not for her attire but for her character. Have you ever compared and contrasted hers and Zechariah's reaction to being visited by Gabriel? They each had quite different reactions- he being an older man as well as a priest and her being a young lady. 

But I left this Scripture night with many thoughts. My main one is where to draw the line? Who gets to decide what is "modest" and what is not. And why do we put so much emphasis on the outward appearance rather than the purity of our hearts? My heart longs for the purity and simplicity of the original design before sin was an issue. We love to heap the responsibility for this sin on women. 

*By the way, 1 Timothy 2:8-10 is not about physical/sexual modesty despite what you may have heard preached or taught. I especially loved the perspective of the Muslim male at my table who focused on verse 8 of this passage and encouraged us in all instances to lift our hands in prayer and not anger.

No comments:

Post a Comment