Our children were all homeschooled until last year when Caleb began attending a specialized school for his learning needs. Being Christians, a lot of our curriculum was Christian-based. We used Veritas Press for a lot of our history. Caleb was working on one of his American History lessons one day, when I realized the portrait of Robert E. Lee being painted for him. It did not sound like the whole story so I did some research. To paint Robert E. Lee as only a good leader both in war and his church seemed like only half the story and it is.
There are multiple credible accounts of the slaves he inherited from his father-in-law and how he treated them including how he did not free them the way his father-in-law intended for him to. There is a letter written to his wife recounting his thoughts on slavery, which seemed to align with many who justified it on the basis of God's sovereignty. I am not saying he was all bad but to paint him as only good did not feel accurate either. One of my favorite history curriculum's we used was written by a woman who worked to present the facts. In helping teach some of her world history lessons, I learned a lot that I had not previously realized.
We do need a more accurate story of so many things but the one I am most passionate about is women.
I wore a shirt to the SBC convention in 2023 that read, "Be a voice, not an echo." I got one complement from a woman on it. We need more voices speaking up and telling the rest of the story, the other side of the story, the more accurate version we have missed out on in so many facets.
This is true of world history events, the founding of our nation, the treatment of native Americans, Christian's role in slavery and segregation, and most important to me, the portrayal of women by the Church.
In order to have a more accurate picture, we have to be willing to question things we once did not, listen to voices once muted and drowned out, and be willing to ask hard questions that threaten to topple long-held traditions.
I recently visited with a friend's mother, who leads a ministry in another country. As we were sharing our struggles with Church, this lady said, "We need teaching, not preaching." I had recently had a conversation with a friend who shared how she struggled to understand the Bible when she read it. So when this comment was shared, I reflected back to the comment about understanding the Bible and saw the correlation. If the majority of what we are fed from the pulpit is interpretation, and that interpretation being from one limited subset of humanity, versus teaching us how to interpret for ourselves, doesn't this handicap us?
I have been in first Corinthians in my Bible reading. I came to chapter eleven the other day and was frustrated. Frustrated that I could not remember what I learned recently about this chapter from the female theologians I have been reading from. Frustrated about how Paul seems to contradict himself in verses eleven and twelve. Frustrated that verses seven through nine, included in the same paragraph as eleven and twelve in my Bible, do not seem to align with all of Scripture or even with all of Paul's writings. I decided to revisit the writings of Lucy Peppiatt, who is the principle of Westminster Theological Centre.
There is a lot to learn about this passage. In her book, Rediscovering Scripture's Vision for Women, Lucy has a whole chapter on this passage but she has also written a whole book on verses two through sixteen of this chapter.
I learned in my deep dive study of chapter fourteen in first Corinthians, that Paul often employed the literary practice of his time of quoting a commonly held idea prior to refuting it in his writings. Learning of this practice illuminated so much and began to dismantle previous contradictions seen in Scripture. From what I have learned about chapter eleven, I would propose Paul is utilizing the same literacy practice here.
I have always been taught to pay attention to the buts and howevers in Scripture and there is one here in verse eleven. I am going to share a portion from Lucy's summary paragraph of this passage but December of last year, she was interviewed on the podcast "Theology in the Raw" and the interview was about this passage. I will share a link to this podcast if you want to learn more.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRQLXeDirs8
"My conclusions are that what is articulated in verses 7-9 describes the corrupted creation story of the Corinthians that was being used to keep women in a particular place in relation to men- in need of a sign of authority. What we see is a creation account being used for a particular purpose. I believe that this account 'places women in a particular place in relation to God and also to man, which then redefines her identity as primarily rooted in her relationship to man rather than to God. Second, it writes her out of her shared role of image and likeness (and glory) bearer and as the creator and bearer of man that we find in Genesis.' This reading has become more and more difficult for scholars to explain away, hence their attempts at coming up with different ways of avoiding this and letting Paul off the hook, none of which succeed. The rhetorical perspective (of Paul in conversation with his opponents) explains the change of tack in verse 11 because it is here where we hear Paul's voice correcting the Corinthians. 'Nevertheless, in the Lord...' There is a different story-a story where men and women are mutually dependent, knowing their debt to one another and their need of one another."